125th Street Subway Tunnel

The BID’s comments to the MTA on the 125th Street subway tunnel

On November 10, 2026, the 125th Street BID sent the MTA its formal comments on the Draft Scoping Document for the 125th Street Subway Tunnel. The BID supports a crosstown subway on 125th Street. Its comments ask the MTA to study, and protect, the businesses, residents and cultural institutions that will live through the construction.

21

requests to the MTA

62

pages of comments

47

exhibits of supporting evidence

The comments are 62 pages (PDF, 1 MB). Download the complete file with all 47 exhibits (PDF, 490 pages, 101 MB).

A tunnel boring machine's cutterhead breaks through rock as a worker in an orange shirt looks on.
Second Avenue Subway tunnel boring machine, 2011. Photo: MTA, CC BY 2.0

In brief

Build the subway, and protect the street while it is built

The MTA says the corridor is home to about 253,000 people and 82,000 jobs. The BID’s comments make the case that the people who have waited decades for this subway should not be the ones it displaces.

13–14 years

Far longer than two years

The MTA’s draft schedules only the tunnel. Counting Second Avenue Subway work already under way and the stations that must follow, the BID estimates 125th Street will host subway construction for about 13 to 14 years, with full service around 2040. It asks the MTA to publish its own estimate. p. 3

1 block

The busiest block takes the hardest hit

The block between Lenox Avenue and Adam Clayton Powell Jr. Boulevard, home to the Studio Museum in Harlem and the Urban League’s Urban Civil Rights Museum, would host Second Avenue Subway staging and then this project’s staging, ground improvement work and truck traffic. p. 2

32%

Second Avenue shows what happens

During the first phase of the Second Avenue Subway, 90% of surveyed businesses said construction hurt them, net sales fell 32% on average, and 98% got no financial support from the MTA. p. 3

30 million+

Measure customers lost, not just buildings

The BID’s ten pedestrian counters record more than 30 million passes a year. The draft’s study of businesses looks for buildings removed and residents added, not customers lost. A scope that does not measure the harm will not produce findings that reduce it. p. 2

Harlem’s merchants, property owners, residents and cultural and community organizations stand to gain from that service, but only if they survive its construction.

125th Street BID comments, Part I, p. 2

A tunnel without a station

Local businesses are being asked to put up with years of disruption to build a tunnel that brings no station, no new riders and no new foot traffic until a later phase. Unlike Second Avenue’s neighborhood retail, 125th Street is a regional shopping destination with a dense concentration of nationally known cultural institutions, so the BID asks the MTA to tailor its protections to the corridor it is building under. p. 8

The requests

21 things the BID asked the MTA to do

The BID asked that the final scope respond to each request by number, and explain why for any it declines. Each link opens the request in the comments.

See all 21 requests
  • Name the candidate sites for construction staging, shafts and vent buildings, and the criteria for choosing them, before the final scope, and study each one. Request 1, p. 26
  • Study the combined, back-to-back staging of both subway projects on the block between Lenox Avenue and Adam Clayton Powell Jr. Boulevard. Keep the combined work site no larger than the Second Avenue Subway’s, and enclose the slurry plant and spoil handling. Request 2, p. 28
  • Treat construction as long-term: publish a timeline for all the work on the corridor and study a delayed-schedule scenario. Request 3, p. 29
  • Count the future stations in the analysis of combined effects, and share preliminary station designs and entrance locations, including on side streets. Request 4, p. 29
  • Study what construction does to businesses while it is under way, measured against a baseline taken before it starts. Request 5, p. 31
  • Identify the properties to be acquired, and give relocation assistance at federal levels whatever the funding source. Request 6, p. 32
  • Study curbs, loading and buses over the full day. Set enforceable standards for access to businesses, and a plan for street vendors. Request 7, p. 34
  • Treat storefronts, restaurants, hotels and performance venues, including the Apollo, as sensitive to noise and vibration; measure the vibration from the tunnel boring machines; and commit to monitoring with stop-work limits and a fast claims process. Request 8, p. 35
  • Measure construction air quality, complete the full disadvantaged-community analysis under the Environmental Justice Siting Law, and commit to clean equipment. Request 9, p. 35
  • Put urban design and visual resources back into the review for the permanent structures. Request 10, p. 37
  • Require construction protection plans and wider condition surveys for older buildings. Request 11, p. 38
  • Study alternatives for sites, sequencing and timing. Request 12, p. 38
  • Make the business protection program, including a construction liaison, a business support fund and access standards, a condition of the MTA’s approval, with contracting goals for local businesses. Request 13, p. 39
  • Bring in NYC Small Business Services, Empire State Development and the City agencies that work on the corridor every day. Form a construction advisory committee and a permanent co-governance committee with the BID, and open an information and grievance office on 125th Street. Request 14, p. 42
  • Correct five drafting errors in the Draft Scoping Document. Request 15, p. 56
  • Study sanitation, rodent control and public safety at the work sites during construction, and state how long each closure will last. Commit in the contracts to rodent control, daily cleaning, lighting, contractor waste removal, reimbursement of the BID’s added costs and indemnity for the BID. Request 16, p. 44
  • Treat the BID’s district plan as public policy; report vacancy, rents and lost assessment revenue; maintain the sidewalks around the permanent structures; and have the MTA’s properties, including any station retail, contribute to the cost of BID services. Request 17, p. 47
  • Respect the Special 125th Street District; protect the Studio Museum, the Urban Civil Rights Museum and the National Black Theatre like the Apollo; protect the BID’s banners, wayfinding and murals; keep the street clear and lit for Harlem Holiday Lights; and commission fence art from Harlem artists. Request 18, p. 49
  • Form a partnership among the MTA, the BID and Columbia’s Center for Smart Streetscapes (CS3) for real-time routing, pedestrian sensors, trash detection, curbside loading reservations, noise and vibration sensors and a daily construction data feed; and support the #HarlemNeatStreetsChallenge. Request 19, p. 53
  • Keep the corridor passable for people with disabilities, older people and parents with strollers, and consult disability organizations on detours and bus stops. Request 20, p. 54
  • Use the BID’s pedestrian counts and Vibe Report for the baseline; tell neighborhood residents from destination visitors; monitor before, during and after construction; schedule closures around Fridays, summer and the holidays; and use Vibemap to share alerts and detours. Request 21, p. 55

Part VII

A business protection program, in place before the first fence goes up

The BID proposes that the MTA make this program a condition of approval and put its terms in a written agreement with the BID before construction begins. Each piece has a precedent in the MTA’s own practice or lessons. Read Part VII, p. 49

Business access standards

Continuous pedestrian access to every door, a minimum clear sidewalk, protected delivery windows and a holiday-season moratorium on new closures.

Visibility and signage

See-through fence panels, business signage and custom fence wraps at every work site from day one.

A construction liaison

A named MTA liaison for 125th Street, a 24-hour hotline and monthly three-month look-ahead schedules.

Marketing and wayfinding

A corridor campaign developed with the BID and launched when work begins, not after sales fall.

A business support fund

Grants and technical assistance, funded as a project cost and run with the BID.

Local procurement

Priority for buying goods and services from corridor businesses during construction.

Building protection

Condition surveys before work starts, real-time vibration monitoring and a fast claims process.

Relocation assistance

No less than federal Uniform Relocation Act levels for anyone displaced, whatever the funding source.

Permanent structure design

Setbacks, landscaping, street-level retail and public space at every vent building and kiosk.

Clean construction

Tier 4 or electric equipment, enclosed slurry and spoil handling, dust controls and public air monitoring.

An advisory committee

Monthly meetings with the BID and community boards from the start of work through restoration.

Corridor upkeep and cultural protection

Rodent control, daily cleaning and lighting at work sites; Harlem Holiday Lights, banners, wayfinding and murals protected.

Read the part that matters to you

Find your part of the comments

The comments are long because the BID backed every point with evidence. Start with the sections written for you. Each link opens the comments at that page.

New to the project? Start with the summary of the BID’s position and what the MTA’s draft proposes, or read about the tunnel project.

The full document

Contents and exhibits

Every source the comments cite is attached as a numbered exhibit. Each exhibit below is its own PDF, so you can open just the one you need.

Table of contents
The MTA’s plans and the rules that govern the review (8)
What Second Avenue Subway construction did to businesses (9)
Court decisions (9)
125th Street’s landmarks, institutions and conditions (17)
The BID’s own data and proposals (4)

PDF · 62 pages · 1 MB

The BID’s comments

The comment letter by itself, Parts I to IX and the exhibit index.

PDF · 490 pages · 101 MB

Complete file with all 47 exhibits

The comments and every exhibit in one file, as sent to the MTA. A large download.

PDF · October 2026

The MTA’s Draft Scoping Document

The document the BID’s comments respond to.

What happens next

Stay with us through the review

  • The MTA reviews the public’s comments and publishes a Final Scoping Document. No date is public yet.
  • The MTA plans to release the Draft Environmental Impact Statement in winter 2027, followed by another public comment period.
  • The construction sites, sequence and properties needed have not been chosen. The BID has reserved the right to add to its comments as that information comes out.